« Shortening the Nicene Creed | Main | Gratitude and Faith: Just Who Should We Be Grateful To? »

November 26, 2004

Comments

bls

I love his points about Jesus - they are all great. Especially the third, "....making his doctrines more respected and more observed." I've never thought about it that way before

This part, too, is so to the point: ...and think it needless to busy myself with it now, when I expect soon an opportunity of knowing the truth with less trouble.

;-)

Greg Jones

Questioning Christian,

I'm glad you question -- this is so wonderful to do. I can't help but notice however that you think it is only right as a Christian to "do the comfortable thing." You said that on a previous posting about "shortening the Nicene Creed" or something like that. Now, I have problems with folks struggling to intellectually assent to the creeds which nearly all Christians have confessed for at least a millenium. But, I wonder, just because something makes you "uncomfortable" or makes you doubt -- is that something which ought simply to be expunged? Especially as regards religious faith, it would seem part of the deal that all religions have certain essential claims which are not expungeable. Whether or not you can subscribe to the religion then ought to be your dilemna but not that of the religion. Franklin as with many of the Enlightenment deleted a good many pieces of the Christian religion which made them uncomfortable. It would appear you like that. But, isn't your enterprise one of inventing your own personal religion? You can say "faith" or "religion" or "tradition" or "doctrine" are not all the same -- and they aren't. But when you go to an Episcopal Church -- that is a religious institution dedicated to faith in Christ as mediated through traditions and doctrines. Should it accomodate you by altering its teachings because you and others aren't able to accept them?

Greg Jones

TYPO ALERT: should have typed "I have NO problems with..."

D. C.

Greg Jones, thanks for the comment. We can't lose sight that a religion is simply a set of beliefs that happen to be held, or to have been held, by a particular group of people. That fact doesn't mean that the beliefs are necessarily right.

I'm far from alone in the Episcopal Church in being less than 100% convinced of all the dogmas we now call orthodox Christianity. If I thought I were alone, or close to it, I doubt I'd still be an Episcopalian.

I have no interest in inventing a personal religion. I'm simply trying to get intellectually-satisfying answers to some of the questions I've had for years -- and that my teen-agers are now asking for themselves. Writing, especially in debates with traditionalists, is an enormous help in that effort.

Thanks for visiting.

Lindsay Wahlstrom

Wow, this was really actually quite moving for me. The first 5 points were so simple and yet so profound! I'm so glad I searched and found this...it may have changed my life forever!!

Lins

philip

please understand ALL of Jesus's teachings before you make judgments about them. any devout christians (followers, not fans of christ) pick up on this. im at school and i dnt have any time to continue

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

Your email address:


Powered by FeedBlitz

Favorite Posts

Adv.

Episcopal Church

  • Come and Grow
Blog powered by Typepad